Emergency? DE

VAT Radar

Briefly assessed, not merely reported: the developments that matter for honest businesses — researched weekly at the CJEU and General Court, BFH, BGH, BVerfG, fiscal courts, EPPO and the supreme courts of the Member States, every entry with its source and what it means for your business.

As of 19.10.2026 · 90 entries since June 2026. Each entry links to the page where we go deeper — and to the service with which we solve the issue for you.

BFH

BFH autumn hearings: the direct claim against the treasury three times on the agenda — and V R 28/24 on the search at a business partner remains pending

The Federal Fiscal Court's official hearing list brings three cases on the EU-law direct claim (Reemtsma line) in November alone: V R 31/24 (19 November 2026) on equitable relief under § 163 AO and the 'EU-law direct claim in insolvency cases', V R 34/24 (19 November 2026) on the claim derived directly from EU law against the tax authority for refund of VAT overpaid to upstream suppliers, and V R 38/24 (26 November 2026) on the direct claim where the recovery claim is time-barred and the supplier has been struck off for lack of assets. On the same day the Fifth Senate hears V R 18/24 (adjustment of input VAT after insolvency clawback), and on 17 December 2026 V R 6/25 (retroactive deduction from invoices issued later after a VAT group was wrongly assumed). Without a hearing date, V R 28/24 (formerly XI R 3/24) remains pending — the case with the question that matters most to traders: must a trader, because of a search of its business partner's premises known to it, (necessarily) assume that its own dealings with that partner are tainted by VAT fraud — and do certificates of fines imposed on the partner trigger a heightened duty of care? V R 38/23 (judgment of 4 December 2025, remittal) and V R 7/24 (judgment of 11 December 2025) have been decided. For businesses whose supplier wrongly charged them VAT, the November hearings decide the route to the treasury; for every trader who learns of an investigation at a business partner, V R 28/24 decides from when continued trading counts as constructive knowledge. The same thing matters in both situations: whoever documented their reaction to the news promptly negotiates from strength. That is precisely the evidence our Proof-of-Check builds — and in a pending case the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK handle the objection and the suspension of enforcement.

BFH, Verhandlungstermine (Stand 19.10.2026) — V R 31/24, V R 34/24, V R 18/24, V R 38/24, V R 6/25; anhängig V R 28/24 (STAH240500028) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Midas': five arrests in a EUR 114 million smartphone carousel — EUR 34 million loss in Germany, missing traders here too

At the request of the European Public Prosecutor's Office in Munich, five suspects were arrested this week — three in Cyprus, one in Germany, one in Italy —, twelve premises in Cyprus, Greece and Italy were searched, accounts of up to EUR 80,000 frozen and cars and real estate seized. According to the investigation, smartphones were traded 'via companies and missing traders based in Germany, Albania and Sweden'; the estimated tax loss is EUR 80 million in Sweden and EUR 34 million in Germany (press release of 16 October 2026). The arrested suspects are believed to have set up and controlled the scheme; on the German side the Bielefeld tax office is involved, and the presumption of innocence is expressly stressed. For traders with smartphone supply chains the risk rises of being hit, as customer or upstream supplier of such a company, with denial of input VAT under § 25f UStG, liability and attachment. The authority must prove knowledge or constructive knowledge separately for each business — whether it succeeds depends on documented supplier checks and the evidenced reaction to warning signs. Our Supplier Traffic-Light Check sets up exactly this audit trail; in an emergency the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK take over the defence against attachment and liability claims.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 16.10.2026 — Investigation Midas (EUStA München) — source

EuGH

CJEU C-321/25 Gidzhinov: a 15-year absolute limitation period for serious VAT fraud complies with EU law

A Bulgarian criminal court asked whether Art. 325 TFEU and the PIF Convention preclude an absolute limitation period of fifteen years that runs regardless of interruption, suspension or fortuitous events — the charge was a criminal organisation for VAT evasion with losses above four million euros (para 35). The Third Chamber answers that the period is permissible 'provided that such a period does not lead, in the Member State concerned, to a systemic risk of impunity for such fraud' (operative part 1; quotations translated from the French). An absolute time bar 'contributes to strengthening legal certainty' by preventing prosecution from being postponed indefinitely through repeated interrupting acts (para 46); fifteen years leave the authorities 'in principle a reasonable period' even for three instances (para 50); changes in the composition of individual panels do not establish a systemic risk (para 51). Secondly, mere conspiracy may carry a higher maximum penalty than the offence itself (operative part 2). The judgment repeatedly cites Lin II of 16 July 2026 (C-280/25). For businesses and managing directors in carousel proceedings the limitation defence remains an instrument of national law that Luxembourg overrides only where a Member State fails systemically. The Court at the same time endorses very long periods and harsher penalties for conspiracy — one more reason to keep old transactions in audit-proof form, because proceedings may begin years after the deal. Which records to retain, and for how long, is defined in the Evidence Pack.

EuGH, Urt. v. 15.10.2026 — C-321/25, Gidzhinov, ECLI:EU:C:2026:859 (Dritte Kammer; SA Campos Sánchez-Bordona v. 23.04.2026, EU:C:2026:350) — source

EuGH

CJEU C-203/25 NEO GROUP: abuse along a chain — knowledge of the distributing company need not be proven

the Lithuanian tax authority applied withholding tax to dividends paid to a parent company because that parent formed part of a chain of wholly or partly non-genuine arrangements through which the money flowed to the controlling person — although the parent itself carried on a real economic activity. The Fourth Chamber holds this permissible in principle under Art. 1(2) and (3) of the Parent-Subsidiary Directive (operative part 1), names as indicia the match between the amounts passed on and the dividends and their continuous transfer over a period of time — always subject to an objective overall assessment (operative part 2) — and finds it irrelevant that the non-genuine steps took place in other Member States (operative part 3). Decisive for the question of proof is operative part 4: the authority need not establish that the distributing subsidiary knew or could have known of the chain, 'provided it is shown that at least one of the group companies participating in that chain, or the natural person who ultimately benefits from the advantage, knew or could have known of its existence' (translated from the French). The judgment concerns withholding tax, but the figure of argument will surface in group supply chains against intermediate companies: knowledge of any group member is supposed to suffice. For § 25f UStG the position remains, after Kittel, Aquila and Global Ink Trade, that the knowledge or constructive knowledge of the specific trader must be proven — and that proof founders on an own, promptly documented audit trail. Our VAT Tax CMS organises roles, information channels and approvals so that the attribution of someone else's knowledge comes to nothing.

EuGH, Urt. v. 15.10.2026 — C-203/25, NEO GROUP, ECLI:EU:C:2026:863 (Vierte Kammer; Vorlage Mokestinių ginčų komisija, Litauen) — source

BMF

Federal Ministry of Finance letter on e-invoicing (15 Oct 2026): a prudent merchant's care as to customer status — no fine for the wrong format

The third application letter on mandatory e-invoicing (ref. III C 5 - S 7287-a/00019/021/017) supplements the letters of 15 October 2024 and 15 October 2025 and announces a further review 'in view of the requirements of the reporting system' to come (para 1). Practically important: a breach of the e-invoicing obligation is not objected to as long as the issuer 'could not recognise with the care of a prudent merchant' that he was supplying another business for its enterprise (para 5); in mass-market business, clarification at the start and on amendment of the contract suffices (para 6). Advance and instalment invoices from the transition period need not be re-issued as e-invoices (para 2), final invoices benefit from non-objection rules until 30 June 2030 (paras 3 f.), and issuing an ordinary invoice instead of an e-invoice is not an administrative offence under § 26a(2) no. 1 UStG (para 28). Further sections cover invoice corrections, business-rule errors and construction services; the administrative VAT guidelines are amended. For invoice issuers this is clear relief: the prudent-merchant standard and a check at the start of the contract suffice — the same logic we apply in the supplier and customer checks of the VAT Tax CMS. The announced recalibration for the reporting system shows at the same time where data-driven enforcement is heading: every invoice becomes a machine-readable object of audit, and the invoice module of the Proof-of-Check keeps your purchase side prepared for it.

BMF, Schreiben v. 15.10.2026 — III C 5 - S 7287-a/00019/021/017, Einführung der obligatorischen elektronischen Rechnung: Ergänzende Regelungen — source

EuG

General Court T-569/25: good faith under the margin scheme belongs in the assessment procedure — not in equitable relief

A German reseller had bought goods on invoices referring to the margin scheme; the tax office denied him the scheme because his suppliers had applied it wrongly and referred him, for his good faith, to a separate equitable-relief procedure (§§ 163, 227 AO). The BFH referred the case. The General Court (Second Chamber, extended composition, no Opinion) first recalls Litdana: the authorities may not deny the margin scheme unless they prove that the trader did not act in good faith or failed to take every reasonable measure available to him (paras 33, 46). It then measures the German practice against the principle of effectiveness: doubled advisory costs across two administrative and two court proceedings (para 40), an overall duration prolonged by 'several years' (para 45) and a relief procedure which 'in general' examines only what the taxpayer himself puts forward (para 47) — together they can make the exercise of the right 'excessively difficult' (para 48). The Federal Government's counter-argument drawn from Schmeink & Cofreth is rejected (para 49). Operative part: read in the light of effectiveness, Art. 314 of the VAT Directive precludes a practice which refuses to consider good faith in the assessment procedure, with its ex officio fact-finding, and relegates it to a separate relief procedure — subject to the BFH's review of the concrete disadvantages. For dealers in second-hand goods — mobile phones, vehicles, precious metals — this means: good faith in the supplier's invoice reference belongs in the tax assessment, and the burden of proving its absence lies with the authority. The idea reaches beyond the margin scheme: wherever the administration wants to grant legitimate-expectation protection only by way of equitable relief, it can be invoked. It can be enforced, however, only with evidenced supplier checks from the time of the transaction — that is the core of the Proof-of-Check, and in the assessment procedure the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK argue it.

EuG, Urt. v. 14.10.2026 — T-569/25, X-GmbH/Finanzamt Y, ECLI:EU:T:2026:666 (Vorlage BFH) — source

EuGH

Review procedure: first CJEU judgment reviewing a General Court preliminary ruling — in the tax case C-167/26 RX AG Kokott proposes to set aside the judgment on the timing of deduction

Since October 2024 the General Court decides preliminary references in VAT matters; the Court of Justice may review such judgments under Art. 256(3) TFEU where the unity or consistency of EU law is at risk. On 8 October 2026 the very first review judgment was delivered (C-108/26 RX, air passenger rights, ECLI:EU:C:2026:838). The second review — and the first in tax — concerns T-689/24: the General Court had held that input VAT may be deducted for the period of supply even if the invoice arrives later but before the return is filed. Advocate General Kokott (Opinion of 10 September 2026) sees a departure from Terra Baubedarf-Handel, Senatex and Aptiv Services Hungary: substantive conditions govern the origin of the right, formal ones the moment it can be exercised; deduction is to be made for the period in which supply and possession of the invoice first coincide. Her proposal (point 88): the General Court's judgment affects the unity and consistency of EU law, the Polish rule is compatible with the Directive. No judgment of the reviewing chamber has been delivered as at 19 October 2026. Substantively nothing changes for German businesses: input VAT deduction remains tied to possession of the invoice (§ 15(1) sentence 1 no. 1 UStG). What matters in practice is something else: a General Court judgment in VAT matters is final only once the review period has expired — whoever relies on a favourable General Court ruling on Kittel or § 25f questions should know its status. We track that status for every decision in our database.

EuGH, Urt. v. 08.10.2026 — C-108/26 RX, ECLI:EU:C:2026:838; Schlussanträge GA Kokott v. 10.09.2026 — C-167/26 RX, Dyrektor Krajowej Informacji Skarbowej, ECLI:EU:C:2026:748 — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Hermes': EUR 410 million carousel with mobile phones — 62 detained, over 300 searches in eight countries, including tax advisers, lawyers and hauliers

The biggest electronics carousel operation of the year: on 7 October 2026 the European Public Prosecutor's Office searched more than 300 premises in Austria, France, Germany, Italy, Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal and Spain — 'the suspects' homes and offices of companies belonging to the organised crime group, as well as tax advisers, lawyers and transport companies' — and had 62 suspects detained (39 in Portugal, 20 in Spain, 3 in Italy). Orders to seize up to EUR 310 million were executed; bank accounts and company shares were frozen, real estate, vehicles, cash and gold coins worth up to EUR 9 million seized. The estimated VAT loss is at least EUR 410 million. According to the investigation, two cooperating syndicates ran separate carousels with a network of intermediary companies in Spain, Italy, Portugal, Austria, France and Malta, used each other's companies, logistics and laundering channels as well as encrypted communication — 'using a similar modus operandi, and partly also the same individuals' as in the Admiral and Moby Dick investigations; one suspect is said to have started afresh in Portugal after a Swedish carousel collapsed. The EPPO offices in Madrid, Porto, Milan, Palermo, Paris, Graz, Valletta, Bucharest, Rotterdam, Vilnius and Frankfurt am Main were involved, as was the Frankfurt tax investigation office. Two conclusions for intermediaries and their advisers: searches expressly reach advisers' offices and hauliers — seizure protection, professional secrecy and the requirements for searches of non-suspects (Federal Constitutional Court, 1 BvR 2232/24) must therefore be checked from day one. And the group's regrouping after earlier action explains why authorities read continued supply relationships after a search as evidence of knowledge: supplier changes and terminations need reasons and documentation. The 72h Readiness Check prepares both; attachment and liability proceedings are handled by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 07.10.2026 — Investigation Hermes (EUStA-Büros u. a. Madrid, Porto, Mailand, Frankfurt am Main) — source

EuG

General Court T-773/25: adding the reverse-charge wording years later does not cure a triangular transaction — good faith does not help here

An Austrian intermediate acquirer had issued invoices without the wording 'reverse charge' and added it only years later in order to rescue the simplification for triangular transactions (Art. 42(a), Art. 197(1)(c) of the VAT Directive). The General Court (Second Chamber, extended composition; German as language of the case) stays on the Luxury Trust Automobil line: the subsequent invoices do not trigger the legal effects of the simplification, and no correction amount may be declared for the current or a future period (operative part). The Commission's suggestion to make retroactive application dependent on the acquirer's good faith or on taxation being secured in the Member State of destination is expressly rejected: that would require a transaction-by-transaction examination and run counter to the aim of simplification (para 43); the Rusedespred case law on correcting wrongly invoiced VAT cannot be transposed, because the issue here is the belated fulfilment of a substantive condition (para 48). For intermediaries in triangular transactions this means: the simplification exists only with a complete invoice at the time of supply; adding the wording later is of no effect, and good faith plays no role in this question. Invoice templates with all mandatory details and a check before dispatch are therefore compulsory — a small module of the VAT Tax CMS with a large effect on the tax burden.

EuG, Urt. v. 07.10.2026 — T-773/25, Finanzamt für Großbetriebe/F GmbH, ECLI:EU:T:2026:638 (Vorlage VwGH, Österreich) — source

EuG

General Court T-529/25: first preliminary ruling with the EPPO as a party — e-bike parts in split shipments are 'disassembled' bicycles

the European Public Prosecutor's Office and the Belgian State are prosecuting importers who had declared parts of Chinese electric bicycles — anti-dumping and countervailing duties attach only to the complete bike — in staggered partial shipments as 'parts'; at first instance fines, imprisonment and confiscation were imposed, the evaded amount exceeded EUR 2.9 million. The General Court (Fifth Chamber, extended composition, with an Opinion of a General Court Advocate General) reads General Rule 2(a) of the Combined Nomenclature broadly: parts invoiced by two suppliers, carried in different containers and declared over several months by the same declarant for the same consignee are to be classified as disassembled electric bicycles — 'provided that objective elements show that those parts form a whole' and comprise all essential components (operative part, translated from the Dutch). For importers of electronics, bicycles and vehicle parts, splitting consignments becomes a customs and criminal-law risk; relief lies in the proviso of 'objective elements' — proof that parts and suppliers were genuinely independent of each other. The form is notable: the European Public Prosecutor's Office appears for the first time as a party to a preliminary-ruling procedure, and from 2028 it will detect such cases from the EU customs data hub. The complete import file therefore belongs in the Evidence Pack today.

EuG, Urt. v. 07.10.2026 — T-529/25, Europäische Staatsanwaltschaft u. Belgische Staat/Prestige Rijwielen u. a., ECLI:EU:T:2026:640 (Vorlage hof van beroep Antwerpen) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Záblesk' (Czechia): indictment in a EUR 196 million electronics fraud — exempt supplies to sham acquirers in Hungary, Poland and Slovakia

On 7 October 2026 the European Public Prosecutor's Office in Ostrava indicted four suspects and proposed plea bargains to Prague's Municipal Court for four more (three of them with five to six years' imprisonment and forfeiture of property). According to the indictment, electronics from Hong Kong, the United Arab Emirates and the United States were imported through Czech companies and then declared as intra-Community supplies to entities in Hungary, Poland and Slovakia which 'had no real economic activity, did not take delivery of the goods, and made no payments'; the goods actually went to warehouses near the Ukrainian border. The loss exceeds CZK 4.8 billion (around EUR 195.7 million); the defendants face up to ten years' imprisonment, forfeiture and ten-year activity bans. For exporters and wholesalers the case shows the risk of losing the exemption where acquirers are fictitious — and at the same time the limit: the supplier's knowledge or constructive knowledge must be established separately, and a functioning control system exonerates (Brno Regional Court in the 100MEGA case). Customer checks, receipt of goods and payment flows therefore belong in the file without gaps; the Supplier Traffic-Light Check covers the customer side as well.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 07.10.2026 — Investigation Záblesk (EUStA Ostrava; Anklage beim Stadtgericht Prag) — source

EPPO

EPPO Turin: eleven arrests in a EUR 100 million VAT fraud with plastics — the goods went to genuine industrial customers

At the request of the European Public Prosecutor's Office in Turin, eight suspects were placed in pre-trial detention and three under house arrest; an order to seize assets of up to EUR 25 million was executed. Between 2018 and 2023 invoices for non-existent transactions totalling EUR 500 million are alleged to have been issued and used, with a VAT loss of around EUR 100 million; shell companies were located in Italy, Austria, Bulgaria, Czechia, Hungary and Romania. The actual recipients — industrial companies in Piedmont, Lombardy and Tuscany — used the plastics in their production. Earlier in the investigation the Tribunal of Nola had already convicted ten suspects, two more were convicted on 21 September 2026. Outside electronics, but instructive: investigators look at the price gap to the market and at the role of the real customers. As long as knowledge or constructive knowledge has not been established, the industrial customer remains an honest market participant — and its best witness is the documented purchase-price comparison that the Supplier Traffic-Light Check provides as a fixed step.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 07.10.2026 — Italien, Turin (Kunststoffhandel; Ermittlungsrichter Turin, Guardia di Finanza) — source

Niederlande

Dutch Supreme Court: tax penalty and criminal prosecution for unpaid VAT — Menci received, duty of coordination reviewable, appeal nonetheless dismissed

A trader was prosecuted for intentionally failing to pay declared VAT (Art. 69a AWR) after the tax administration had already imposed default penalties under Art. 67c AWR. The Advocate General at the Supreme Court had proposed on 23 June 2026 (ECLI:NL:PHR:2026:845) that the appeal be dismissed; the Criminal Chamber follows on 6 October 2026 (ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1578), but sets guard-rails: prosecuting VAT duties is implementation of EU law (para 2.2.2); the national notion of 'the same act' does not coincide with 'the same offence' in Art. 50 of the Charter (para 2.6.1); the coordination protocol between tax administration and prosecution service must be applied so that cases with partly identical facts are coordinated, and a plea that the decision to prosecute was taken without the coordination required by Art. 50 must be decided with reasons by the trial court — reviewable on cassation (para 2.6.3); in a second prosecution after a prior sanction the criminal court must ensure, in sentencing, the proportionality of the cumulative burdens (para 2.6.4). A reference to the CJEU is considered unnecessary in view of Menci (para 2.8). The dual track of administrative sanction and criminal prosecution thus remains permissible; what is gained is a reviewable duty of coordination and proportionality control of the overall burden. Both ideas transfer to the German coexistence of surcharges, denial of input VAT under § 25f UStG and criminal proceedings — and belong in the strategy that the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK develop for the tax proceedings running alongside the criminal case.

Hoge Raad (Strafkamer), Urt. v. 06.10.2026 — ECLI:NL:HR:2026:1578; Schlussantrag AG v. 23.06.2026 — ECLI:NL:PHR:2026:845 — source

FG

Münster Fiscal Court 5 K 694/17 U (appeal V R 31/25): constructive knowledge in a precious-metals chain — the tax office bears the burden of proof, but unenforced checks weigh against the trader

In the second round after BFH XI B 30/20, the Fifth Senate denies a precious-metals dealer input VAT: despite numerous warning signs it kept buying from suspicious suppliers and did not enforce its own checks (paras 211–220). At the same time the court holds that the tax office must prove constructive knowledge (paras 158, 160) and applies an objective standard without any element of fault — against voices in case law and literature that require fault (para 156, citing among others Spilker, UR 2023, 589). An appeal has been lodged; the Münster court lists it as V R 31/25, while the case number could not yet be found in the BFH database on 19 October 2026. It is the test case on the standard of constructive knowledge; para 156 is the point of attack on appeal. For practice the judgment confirms the core thesis of the Proof-of-Check: a rule of verification that exists on paper and is not lived does not exonerate — an enforced and documented system does. Whether your system performs this evidential function today is what the Quick Scan shows in ten questions.

FG Münster, Urt. v. 17.03.2025 — 5 K 694/17 U, ECLI:DE:FGMS:2025:0317.5K694.17U.00 (Revision: V R 31/25 laut Revisionsliste des FG) — source

Tschechien

Brno, 100MEGA Distribution: a functioning supplier-vetting system exonerates the electronics exporter — but not where warning signs were ignored

After remittal by the Supreme Administrative Court, the Brno Regional Court had to reassess the subjective element (judgment of 9 April 2026, accessible since 1 September 2026). Result: annulment for the periods involving the suppliers Doxa and Nina, dismissal for the supplier La koruna. On Doxa the court holds that the claimant 'has undoubtedly discharged its burden of proof'; the remaining lapses — no proven personal contact, inconsistent checking of suspiciously low prices, no audit trail of the supervisor's approval — are 'not so serious that a total failure of the control system … could be inferred', but 'partial stumbles which, when applying an otherwise well-designed system, are to some extent understandable and tolerable in practice' (para 195, translated). Para 198 draws the line: random checks of serial numbers are 'extraordinarily effective' because duplicates are the 'unmistakable sign' of a carousel — yet when the claimant did find duplicates in one case its reaction was 'very lukewarm', and 'without a genuine effort to verify suspicious facts and without an adequate reaction, no internal control system can be regarded as a sufficient measure'. For La koruna the policy had been applied 'so formally and inconsistently' that it could 'only be described as negligent' (para 193). Procedural status: the tax administration withdrew its cassation appeal against the exonerating part on 4 May 2026 (NSS, 1 Afs 48/2026, order of 22 June 2026) — that part is unassailable; the claimant's appeal against the dismissing part is still pending. The value of a functioning control system can hardly be evidenced more clearly: it can exclude constructive knowledge, and minor gaps do not devalue a well-designed system. The flip side is equally clear: what decides is the documented reaction to the warning sign — serial-number duplicates left without consequence cost the deduction. Precisely this reaction trail — warning sign, assessment, approval, time stamp — is the core of the Proof-of-Check.

Krajský soud v Brně, Urt. v. 09.04.2026 — 30 Af 21/2022-425, 100MEGA Distribution, ECLI:CZ:KSBR:2026:30.Af.21.2022.425; NSS, Beschl. v. 22.06.2026 — 1 Afs 48/2026-44 — source

BFH

BFH VII B 24/25: 'taxpayer or liable person' — the alternative assessment is seriously doubtful, suspension without security

The main customs office had issued an assessment that left open whether the person concerned was the taxpayer or — for tax evasion or receiving untaxed goods — a liable person under § 71 AO. The Seventh Senate sets aside the Hessian Fiscal Court's refusal and suspends enforcement of the assessment without security until one month after the judgment in the main proceedings (order of 10 September 2026, published 1 October 2026). Headnote: under the more recent case law it is 'not settled and therefore seriously doubtful whether an alternative assessment is permissible in tobacco tax law' where, on the facts found, either tax liability or secondary liability comes into consideration. Tax liability and secondary liability 'are mutually exclusive' (Senate judgment VII R 56/18); whether the Senate adheres to its 1983 view on the admissibility of such assessments is reserved for the main proceedings. Decided in tobacco tax law, but the idea carries into every liability procedure: the authority must assign the role — taxpayer or liable person — and an 'either-or assessment' is no sound basis for enforcement. At the same time a precedent for the suspension standard: an unsettled legal position means suspension without security. With this argument the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK challenge liability notices under § 71 AO.

BFH, Beschl. v. 10.09.2026 — VII B 24/25 (AdV), ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:BA.100926.VIIB24.25.0 — source

FG

Schleswig-Holstein Fiscal Court 1 K 62/24 (appeal VII R 14/25): no director's liability after a valid removal — the tax office must substantiate a 'company burial'

The fiscal court set aside a former managing director's liability for VAT because he had been validly removed before the relevant periods; the tax office must substantiate an alleged 'company burial' in concrete terms, and a successor in another EU country is not enough. The Federal Fiscal Court admitted the appeal and has already heard the case as VII R 14/25; no decision had been published by 19 October 2026. Liability requires office in the relevant period, and the burden of investigating a burial scheme lies with the tax office — typical of straw-man changes to other EU countries, where the administration likes to pursue the last managing director within reach. Removal, register entry and handover record therefore belong in every managing director's personal file; in liability proceedings under §§ 69, 34 AO the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK provide representation.

Schleswig-Holsteinisches FG, Urt. v. 27.09.2024 — 1 K 62/24, ECLI:DE:FGSH:2024:0927.1K62.24.00 (Revision BFH VII R 14/25) — source

FG

Two new appeals: invoice bearing the supplier's future name (V R 18/26) and late-payment surcharges despite the tax later falling away (V R 12/26)

The Berlin-Brandenburg Fiscal Court (judgment of 12 November 2025 — 5 K 5140/24) denied input VAT because the invoice already bore the supplier's new name, not yet entered in the register — although tax number and register number were correct; good faith did not help. The BFH admitted the appeal (V R 18/26: denial of deduction solely because the supplier's future name is stated?). The Munich Fiscal Court (judgment of 3 March 2026 — 5 K 1704/24) let late-payment surcharges stand although the tax later fell away following a CJEU judgment, because the EU-law doubts had not been raised in the suspension proceedings; appeal V R 12/26 (remission of surcharges after refusal of suspension and later amendment). Two practical rules follow. Formal errors without any fraud element must not cost the deduction where the supplier's identity is established — a proportionality question of the Barlis/Senatex line that the BFH will now answer. And whoever applies for suspension of enforcement in carousel cases raises every ground of doubt at once and in full — Kittel burden of proof, proportionality, EU law — otherwise the surcharges remain even if the case is later won. That is how the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK build suspension applications.

FG Berlin-Brandenburg, Urt. v. 12.11.2025 — 5 K 5140/24, ECLI:DE:FGBEBB:2025:1112.5K5140.24.00 (Revision V R 18/26); FG München, Urt. v. 03.03.2026 — 5 K 1704/24 (Revision V R 12/26) — source

Polen

Poland's Supreme Administrative Court: perfect paperwork as a hallmark of fraud, dropping suppliers once the authorities take interest as evidence of knowledge — but sector warnings do not replace case-specific findings

Four final judgments of the Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny from the electronics trade, newly available in the court's database: in I FSK 2018/23 and 2019/23 (14 July 2026, mobile phones) the court characterises carousel fraud as marked 'also by the completeness and meticulousness of the documentation on invoicing, payment and forwarding', designed to give the administration 'no reason for doubt' — which is why examining the entire supply chain was justified. In I FSK 276/23 (10 June 2026) the court treated the fact that the company 'repeatedly broke off cooperation with entities once the tax authorities began to take an interest in their activity' as proof of conscious participation; litigation against suppliers after the authorities' interest became known was read as simulated diligence. Pointing the other way, I FSK 467/23 (9 June 2026, LEDs and storage media): good faith requires 'individualised findings' on the specific business relationship; generic references to the ministries' 2014 warning letter, to heightened standards of care or to the omitted review of the supply chain 'could not, on their own, … form a basis' for alleging a lack of commercial diligence (section 6.3.3) — the administration's appeal failed as did the company's. For the design of a control system this is a warning: documentation without substance checks — price against distributor price, volumes, origin — is turned against the trader, and ending a supply relationship after official enquiries needs a reasoned, dated note. I FSK 467/23 at the same time supplies the counter-argument against blanket allegations drawn from sector warnings. Plausibility checks and decision notes are therefore fixed components of the Supplier Traffic-Light Check.

NSA (Polen), Urt. v. 14.07.2026 — I FSK 2018/23 und I FSK 2019/23; Urt. v. 10.06.2026 — I FSK 276/23; Urt. v. 09.06.2026 — I FSK 467/23 (CBOSA) — source

Bulgarien

Bulgaria's Supreme Administrative Court: fraud must be proven, not presumed — thinly resourced suppliers and refuted carrier statements do not support a denial

Two final decisions in favour of taxpayers: in no. 9390 of 1 October 2026 (recipient of vehicle repairs and parts; input VAT of BGN 470,757) the panel holds that the administration 'has not established that the trading company participated in VAT fraud and knew or should have known that the disputed transactions were part of such fraud'; inferences from the supplier's lack of staff and material resources could justify a denial 'only' if the invoice recipient's knowledge or constructive knowledge was established — 'such objective data have not been established by the authorities' (translated). In no. 9294 of 29 September 2026 (car dealer, intra-Community supplies to Greece) documents from the tax administration, traffic police and border police 'categorically' refuted the carriers' statements that they had not transported the vehicles; the supplier 'acted in good faith' and 'took the possible and reasonable measures' (Teleos, Mecsek-Gabona). Pointing the other way, no. 9409 of 1 October 2026: used cars from a French lease-return supplier were an intra-Community acquisition and the margin scheme remained denied — no fraud case, but the § 25a risk when sourcing from other EU countries. Two counter-authorities to the administration's indicia logic: supplier deficiencies are no proof of fraud, and proof of transport can be furnished through official data when witnesses change their story — a parallel to the good-faith protection of § 6a(4) UStG. Whoever secures transport documents, collection authorisations and vehicle data per delivery in the Evidence Pack has this proof when it counts.

Varhoven administrativen sad (Bulgarien), Entscheidungen Nr. 9390 v. 01.10.2026 (adm. d. 5761/2026), Nr. 9294 v. 29.09.2026 (adm. d. 6675/2026) und Nr. 9409 v. 01.10.2026 (adm. d. 6747/2026) — source

Gesetzgebung

Customs Finance Justice Act and Annual Tax Act 2026 in the Bundestag: Bundesrat wants a gang aggravator for all taxes and a reversed burden of proof in confiscation — Government rejects the reversal

On 30 September 2026 the Federal Government transmitted both bills to the Bundestag (Bundestag printed papers 21/8282 and 21/8283), each with the Bundesrat's opinion of 25 September 2026 and the Government's reply. The draft Customs Finance Justice Act creates a procedure for confiscating assets of unclear origin: the court orders confiscation 'if, on the basis of its free conviction drawn from the overall result of the proceedings, it is satisfied that the assets are not of lawful origin' (§ 62(1) draft Customs Criminal Investigation Act), with the person concerned bearing the burden of explaining their origin. The Bundesrat goes further and demands an express reversal of the burden of proof (no. 16) — 'the Federal Government rejects the proposal' —, a gang aggravator for all types of tax in § 370(3) sentence 2 no. 5 AO which, through the catalogue reference in § 100a(2) no. 2a of the Code of Criminal Procedure, would also open up telephone surveillance (no. 29) — the Government 'supports the intention' and announces its own act against tax crime with wider sentencing ranges —, and more consistent third-party confiscation in cases of asset shifting (no. 41), for which a further asset-recovery bill is to be tabled this year. §§ 14c and 25f UStG are untouched in both bills. Government and Länder are converging: confiscation without proof of an offence, a gang aggravator with telecommunications surveillance, third-party confiscation. For traders holding cash and stock the risk rises that assets are secured before any guilt is decided. The rejection of the reversed burden of proof, the hardship clause (§ 62(3)) and decision by judgment are the points to be secured in the legislative process — and documenting the origin of one's own assets becomes a precautionary task that the Evidence Pack covers.

Deutscher Bundestag, BT-Drs. 21/8282 (Zollfinanzgerechtigkeitsgesetz) und 21/8283 (Jahressteuergesetz 2026) v. 30.09.2026, jeweils mit Stellungnahme des Bundesrates v. 25.09.2026 (Nr. 16, 29, 41) und Gegenäußerung der Bundesregierung — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Troja': over one million used phones sold as new — 160 searches in 19 countries, the margin scheme as the abuse model

Since 26 September 2026 the European Public Prosecutor's Office in Cologne has been conducting searches and arrests against an organisation which, according to the investigation, had mobile phones assembled from used components in Hong Kong and the United Arab Emirates, shipped them cleaned and packaged as new to the Netherlands, stored them in German warehouses and sold them on online marketplaces to end customers across the EU. 1,770 officers carried out over 160 searches and seizures in 19 states, seven suspects — including the two leaders — were arrested in Austria, Germany and Spain; the damage is put at least EUR 300 million for consumers and over EUR 30 million in VAT. The tax mechanism: shell companies in Austria, Bulgaria, Germany, the Netherlands and Switzerland allegedly applied the margin scheme to the sales since 2018 — it applies 'only to resold goods on which VAT had been paid already', whereas for goods sold as new VAT is due on the full price. The investigation was triggered by an OLAF report. Together with the Frankfurt case (new phones 'as used'), § 25a UStG is now in the investigators' focus in both directions. For dealers and marketplace sellers this means: whoever buys from margin-scheme traders verifies and documents second-hand status and the reseller chain — after General Court T-569/25 good faith counts in the tax assessment, but only when evidenced. For the mobile and electronics wholesale trade we have built these steps into the Supplier Traffic-Light Check.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 29.09.2026 — Investigation Troja (EUStA Köln; Europol, Eurojust, OLAF) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Escape Room': broker arrested in Rotterdam, first indictment in Poland — electronics carousel with a network reaching into Germany

Two follow-up reports from the investigation into VAT carousels with electronic devices spanning Austria, Belgium, Germany, Latvia, the Netherlands and Poland: at the request of the European Delegated Prosecutors in Rotterdam another suspect was arrested (questioned on 16 September 2026, remanded in custody), who allegedly acted as a broker between links in the chain and claimed refunds to which he was not entitled — his share of the damage is put at around EUR 4 million, the total at EUR 22 million in the Netherlands and EUR 47 million in Belgium; EUR 3.5 million were secured, including real estate, vehicles, stock and receivables (press release of 22 September 2026). On 29 September 2026 the EPPO in Katowice filed the investigation's first indictment, against two Polish nationals; the invoice volume in Poland exceeds EUR 100 million, the sentencing range runs up to 25 years. The broker level — the typical position of a wholesaler — is in focus, and with stock and receivables the seizure hits the running business. The pattern 'carrying on through new companies after searches' will be held against customers who keep buying after measures have become known — the legal question in the case V R 28/24 pending before the BFH. Whoever reviews, documents and where necessary ends supply relationships after such news already has the answer in the file; the Supplier Traffic-Light Check provides for this step expressly.

EPPO, Pressemitteilungen v. 22.09.2026 (Rotterdam) und 29.09.2026 (Katowice) — Investigation Escape Room — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Admiral 2.0' (Riga): five convictions in a carousel at the expense of the French and German treasuries

At the request of the European Public Prosecutor's Office, the Riga City Court convicted five persons by plea agreement of tax evasion in an organised group — fines totalling EUR 429,000, probation supervision of three to five years and bans on any commercial activity for up to three years; three further persons had been convicted earlier. According to the press release of 29 September 2026 the damage of EUR 1.13 million was caused to the budgets of France and Germany; the carousel followed the same modus as the large Admiral investigation, and over 400 companies are under suspicion. A small offshoot showing two things: the European Public Prosecutor's Office pursues losses to the German treasury from abroad as well, and plea agreements with activity bans are becoming the standard conclusion. For companies in the chain that is a reason to secure their own evidence before third-party confessions shape the file — access to the file under Glencore and the Evidence Pack are the tools for that.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 29.09.2026 — Investigation Admiral 2.0 (EUStA Riga) — source

BGH

Grand Criminal Panel: extended confiscation under § 73a StGB also for objects no longer in the defendant's assets at the time of the trigger offence

On a referral, the Grand Criminal Panel decided (order of 1 June 2026, released 29 September 2026, designated for publication in the official reports): extended confiscation under § 73a(1) StGB of an object obtained through or for another unlawful act does not require that the object was physically present in the defendant's assets when the trigger offence was committed. A dispute between the criminal senates is thus resolved in favour of broad asset recovery. In tax-crime proceedings with asset attachment, extended confiscation thus reaches values that had already left the defendant's assets before the trigger offence; together with the plans for confiscating assets of unclear origin, the balance shifts further towards recovery. Whoever can present the origin of their assets early and with evidence keeps enforcement within limits — the asset documentation in the Evidence Pack provides for that, and in attachment proceedings under § 324 AO the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK provide representation.

BGH, Beschl. v. 01.06.2026 — GSSt 1/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:010626BGSST1.25.0 (BGHSt; eingestellt 29.09.2026) — source

BGH

BGH 1 StR 469/24: input VAT reduces the evaded amount — and saved taxes may not be confiscated from the managing director via § 71 AO

In a network of hotel-cleaning companies, social-security wages were under-reported and VAT returns not filed; the Frankfurt am Main Regional Court sentenced the sole shareholder — initially formal, later de facto managing director — to five years for withholding social-security contributions in 889 cases and tax evasion in 103 cases and confiscated EUR 6,551,229.53. The First Criminal Senate (judgment of 27 November 2025, released 24 September 2026) quashes the individual sentences in the VAT cases and the confiscation. First, the trial court had established deductible input VAT but based sentencing on the higher output VAT figures: that would be correct 'at most if there is no direct and immediate link between the input and output transactions. Otherwise the input VAT must already be deducted when determining the respective evaded amounts, because the compensation bar (§ 370(4) sentence 3 AO) does not apply' (para 23). Second, confiscation of saved expenses from the managing director fails: it presupposes that the participant 'can actually dispose of those savings'; saved taxes can be confiscated only from the person 'who was already obliged to pay the taxes before the offence was committed. A mere liability debt under § 71 AO — arising only because of the offence — does not suffice' (para 28). Confiscation would have had to be directed against the companies (para 29); the Senate does not set it aside entirely, because the new trial court might establish a reward for the offence (para 30). Two standard arguments for carousel and missing-trader proceedings: the evaded amount is open to challenge if the direct link to input VAT was not examined — relevant for businesses with real supplies whose input VAT is merely 'denied' —, and confiscation from the officer or the person behind the scenes requires actual receipt, not the liability construct of § 71 AO (continuing the line of 6 StR 463/25 and 3 StR 202/25). The tax proceedings alongside the criminal case — liability, attachment, suspension — are handled by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK; the calculation of the evaded amount is the first point they check.

BGH, Urt. v. 27.11.2025 — 1 StR 469/24, ECLI:DE:BGH:2025:271125U1STR469.24.0 (eingestellt 24.09.2026) — source

Tschechien

Czech Supreme Administrative Court: tax 'by virtue of the invoice' is no penalty for fraud — without risk to revenue, no double charge

A claimant had fictitiously 'purchased' solar panels and invoiced fictitious installations to final consumers; the administration denied the input VAT and additionally assessed the tax shown on the invoices. The 21st Senate (judgment of 30 June 2026, accessible since 31 August 2026) dismisses the administration's cassation appeal: since the invoices went to final consumers, 'the risk of a loss of tax revenue was excluded'; the authority 'should not have assessed the tax at all', and in the result it was the authority itself that infringed neutrality 'by increasing state revenue although no supply had been made and there was no risk of a tax loss' — the provision is 'not a new “penalty” for fraudulent conduct' but merely a safeguard for the case of a threatened deduction at the customer (para 34, translated). Even the intentional, fraudulent character of the conduct does not permit assessing 'a “further” tax alongside the denial of the deduction'; other means of tax and criminal law exist for that (para 35). The Brno Regional Court applies the line in TRUCK TRADE (31 August 2026) to a circular deal with seven lorries: the circular form alone does not exclude the risk, but if no tax was lost anywhere in the circle, correction may not be refused merely because the customer deducted the tax (para 45); the administration must examine the submission on chain-wide neutrality (paras 46 f.) — a cassation appeal has been lodged against this. The quarter's strongest European authority against cumulating denial of input VAT with tax by virtue of the invoice in chain and circular transactions: the condition is a risk to revenue, not fraudulent intent — parallel to Berlin-Brandenburg Fiscal Court 2 K 2046/25 and to the over-compensation critique of § 25f UStG. Whoever is charged several times along one chain now has a comparative-law argument; the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK deploy it in objections and actions.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 30.06.2026 — 21 Afs 215/2025-67, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:21.Afs.215.2025.67; Krajský soud v Brně, Urt. v. 31.08.2026 — 30 Af 34/2023-46, TRUCK TRADE, ECLI:CZ:KSBR:2026:30.Af.34.2023.46 (Kassationsbeschwerde eingelegt) — source

BFH

BFH V R 17/24: who supplies is determined by contract and outward conduct — not by the flow of payments

An intermediary arranging vehicle rentals had collected the full price; the tax office and the Cologne Fiscal Court treated this as a concealed transaction on her own account. The Fifth Senate sets this aside and upholds the action (judgment of 21 May 2026, published 24 September 2026). Headnote: an intermediary in a vehicle rental does not, at any rate, carry out a concealed own transaction where she has not rented the vehicle herself. The reasoning rests on the EU line from Newey and Fenix International: where the legal relationship follows from contractual agreements, those agreements determine who supplies and who receives, because the contractual position 'normally reflects the economic and commercial reality of the transactions' — differently only where the contractual terms 'constitute a purely artificial arrangement' (para 16). The flow of payments 'is not decisive for determining who is the supplier' (para 20); collecting the full price changes nothing (para 22). The Senate regards the older case law on concealed own transactions in the used-car trade as possibly superseded in the light of the margin scheme. A judgment without any fraud element, but with leverage against the 'economic view' by which tax audits construct supply chains from payment routes: contract and outward conduct take precedence, the only reservation being the 'purely artificial arrangement' under Newey — the word 'abuse' does not appear in the judgment. For agency and intermediary models in the vehicle and electronics trade this means: contracts, terms and outward appearance belong in the Evidence Pack, because they carry the attribution.

BFH, Urt. v. 21.05.2026 — V R 17/24, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.210526.VR17.24.0 (veröffentlicht 24.09.2026) — source

Tschechien

NSS GREGOCAR: used-car dealer bears the burden of proving the reseller chain — his suppliers' breaches count against him

A used-car dealer had applied the margin scheme to vehicles from foreign suppliers; the administration denied it for 24 periods (CZK 28.3 million plus a penalty surcharge). The 4th Senate (judgment of 30 July 2026, accessible since 31 August 2026) confirms: fulfilment of the statutory conditions 'must be proven by the dealer who applies the special scheme to his own transactions'; the claimant should have shown that its suppliers belonged to the eligible group and had actually applied the scheme towards it — the argument that the suppliers' breaches must not be held against it 'misses the point' (para 26, translated); the Kemwater principles on proving the supplier apply by analogy (para 23). The counter-position to General Court T-569/25 and Litdana: there, good faith in the invoice reference protects; here, the burden of proof for the whole chain lies with the dealer. For car dealers with an EU dimension this means archiving suppliers' status evidence vehicle by vehicle — and, in Germany, insisting on good-faith protection in the assessment procedure. Both are built into the Evidence Pack for the vehicle trade.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 30.07.2026 — 4 Afs 138/2025-41, GREGOCAR, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:4.Afs.138.2025.41 — source

EU-Recht

New Union Customs Code in force: EU customs data hub, EPPO data access from July 2028

Regulation (EU) 2026/2108 of 16 September 2026 (OJ L of 19 September 2026) replaces the 2013 Customs Code, establishes an EU Customs Authority and a central EU customs data hub. It entered into force on 20 September 2026 and applies in principle from 21 September 2027 (Art. 287(1) and (2)); the provisions on the data hub and data access — Art. 41 (except paragraph 10) and Arts. 42 to 45 — apply only from 1 July 2028 (Art. 287(5)(b)). The hub is to support, among other things, the calculation and notification of the customs debt, import VAT and excise duty, and to carry risk and data analytics 'including through the use of artificial intelligence systems' (Art. 41(3)). For importers of mobile phones, electronics and vehicles a central, machine-readable data source emerges, accessible to customs, tax authorities and — under Art. 42 — the European Public Prosecutor's Office; patterns such as the US salvage cars in the Nimmersatt case or the split shipments of T-529/25 will become visible through data matching. The complete import file — customs declaration, import duty assessment, proof of origin — therefore belongs in the Evidence Pack today.

Verordnung (EU) 2026/2108 des Europäischen Parlaments und des Rates v. 16.09.2026 (Zollkodex der Union, EU-Zollbehörde), ABl. L 2026/2108 v. 19.09.2026 — source

EU-Recht

Commission evaluates the EPPO: 2,030 investigations and EUR 1.13 billion in freezing orders in 2025 — gaps in defence rights

The first evaluation report under Art. 119 of the EPPO Regulation (COM(2026) 491 final, 18 September 2026) presents a success story: investigations opened 576 (2021) against 2,030 (2025), freezing orders granted at the EPPO's request EUR 147.3 million against EUR 1.13 billion, indictments 5 against 275, convictions 1 against 159; at the end of 2025 the EPPO handled 3,602 active cases instead of the roughly 970 assumed in its financial statement. The Commission concedes at the same time that differences in national procedural safeguards and shortcomings in transposing the procedural-rights directives impair the uniformity of defence rights in EPPO proceedings, 'in particular as regards legal aid, access to the file, translation practices and standards for pre-trial detention', and that robust data on final outcomes, acquittals and amounts actually recovered are only partly available because Member States are under no duty to report. The EUR 10 million competence threshold for cross-border VAT fraud is described unchanged. The official finding of uneven defence rights can be invoked in every EPPO case (Art. 41 of the EPPO Regulation, Arts. 47, 48 of the Charter) — for instance where access to the file or translation is refused; the figures also show that freezing and attachment have become standard tools. Both argue for preparation before the first contact: the 72h Readiness Check defines who does what in an emergency, and the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK enforce access to the file and the defence against attachment.

Europäische Kommission, Bericht über die Durchführung und die Auswirkungen der Verordnung (EU) 2017/1939 über die Europäische Staatsanwaltschaft, COM(2026) 491 final v. 18.09.2026 (mit SWD(2026) 278) — source

EuGH

Opinion in C-407/25 Tersten: failure to inform the EPPO does not render the national indictment inadmissible

Belgian customs investigated customs offences in imports from China with consignees in Germany, Spain and Hungary in 2019/2020; the summonses were issued in summer 2021 — after the EPPO had started work — without the EPPO being informed under Art. 24(2) of the EPPO Regulation. Advocate General Campos Sánchez-Bordona proposes to the Grand Chamber: national authorities remain competent until the EPPO evokes the case, and the omission does not bar the indictment (point 117); automatic loss of competence, let alone nullity of the investigation and inadmissibility of evidence, would be disproportionate (points 66–68), the sanction being infringement proceedings (point 69). At the same time: the authorities must inform the EPPO belatedly, the EPPO may still evoke the case at the judicial stage, but must then ensure that its decisions on evidence, the assessment of the facts and sentencing do not prejudice the rights the accused enjoy under national law (point 114); the consequences of the breach are governed by national procedural law (points 110–113). The plea 'EPPO not informed, hence a procedural bar' fails on the Advocate General's view. What remains open is the route through national law: late reports by tax investigation or customs are to be challenged as procedural errors, and point 114 is the anchor against any deterioration of the evidential position after a change of authority. In EPPO proceedings the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK check competence and evocation as the first step.

Schlussanträge GA Campos Sánchez-Bordona v. 17.09.2026 — C-407/25, Tersten, ECLI:EU:C:2026:767 (Große Kammer; Vorlage Hof van beroep te Brussel) — source

EPPO

EPPO Frankfurt: new phones sold to German consumers under the margin scheme — asset recovery also from the online retailers and their managers

On 16 September 2026 the European Public Prosecutor's Office in Frankfurt am Main had premises searched in Austria, Bulgaria, Cyprus and Germany; four suspects were arrested (three in Bulgaria, one in Germany), and the investigative court in Frankfurt issued asset-freezing orders of around EUR 20.5 million against two suspects and two companies. According to the investigation, new mobile phones were passed through a chain of Bulgarian, Cypriot and German companies and sold to consumers by German online retailers under the VAT margin scheme — VAT on the margin only instead of on the full price, estimated losses above EUR 15.7 million. Crucial for practice: 'In parallel, the competent German authorities in Braunschweig and Berlin are taking measures to recover assets from the companies that sold the mobile phones and from their managers'; EUR 3.3 million have already been recovered from one of the suspected companies. Enforcement does not stop at the organiser of the chain but reaches the seller level. For dealers the margin scheme holds only with a documented reseller chain (Art. 314 of the VAT Directive, § 25a(1) no. 2 UStG) and a verified upstream supplier; new goods 'as second-hand', prices well below market and suppliers without a trading history are this case's warning signs — the Supplier Traffic-Light Check turns them into a step before purchase. Legally connected are good faith under General Court T-569/25 and the good-faith question of the new reference T-435/26.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 17.09.2026 — Deutschland, Verfahren der EUStA Frankfurt am Main (Mobiltelefone, Differenzbesteuerung) — source

BVerfG

Federal Constitutional Court: searching non-suspects requires a concrete expectation of finding evidence — mere proximity to the accused is not enough

Two constitutional complaints against searches under § 103 of the Code of Criminal Procedure succeeded (orders of 3 August 2026, published with press release no. 56/2026 on 17 September 2026): non-suspect flatmates had been searched merely because of the shared address — in one case with 14 search warrants for one building, 13 of them against non-suspects. The Second Chamber of the First Senate clarifies: for the suspect, § 102 requires only an abstract expectation of finding evidence and covers all rooms he shares, 'but also … work, business and commercial premises' (para 14); for the non-suspect, § 103 demands 'concrete reasons' why the evidence sought can be found precisely in the premises used by him alone (para 15), 'further indications as concrete grounds' going 'beyond vague clues and mere suppositions' (para 16) — and as a 'concrete expectation existing already at the time the search is ordered' (para 21). Prosecution is not impeded: if indications arise on the spot, a § 103 order can be obtained through the on-call investigating judge; 'quasi-prophylactic' warrants against all non-suspects are unnecessary (para 24). The facts concern shared flats; the transfer to business premises is obvious: whoever merely traded with the accused is, like the mere flatmate, not a search target 'in reserve'. In carousel and EPPO proceedings — most recently 'Hermes' with searches of advisers and hauliers — checking the addressee of the warrant (§ 102 or § 103, sole or shared premises) is the first step; the 72h Readiness Check defines it, the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK lodge the complaint.

BVerfG, Beschl. v. 03.08.2026 — 1 BvR 2232/24, ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2026:rk20260803.1bvr223224; 1 BvR 2399/24, ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2026:rk20260803.1bvr239924 (PM Nr. 56/2026 v. 17.09.2026) — source

Tschechien

NSS SQUADRA and MK auto trading: a tax loss in the chain is not yet fraud — but mobile-phone warning signs work as a bundle

Two judgments of the Supreme Administrative Court, both accessible since 31 August 2026, mark the poles of the Kittel test. SQUADRA (23 July 2026; golf equipment bought from a sister company with the same managing director, set-off, night-time loading, cancellation and criminal complaint by the second director, tax not remitted): the administration's cassation appeal is dismissed. At the first step 'it is not enough to identify any tax evasion in the chain of transactions' — the circumstances must support the conclusion that the breach of neutrality 'was driven by fraudulent intent' (para 39); 'the burden of proving the existence of VAT fraud lies with the tax administration' (para 40); at the link where the tax went missing, the intent to obtain an undue advantage must be present at least as a well-founded presumption (para 45); a 'mere enumeration of non-standard circumstances' without engaging with the plausible alternative explanation — here the shareholder dispute — does not suffice (paras 47–50, translated). MK auto trading (10 July 2026, mobile phones): the denial is upheld. The authorities bear the burden of proving fraud and the objective circumstances (para 28), but refuting each indicator in isolation would 'empty' the knowledge test; trading in mobile phones as a risk commodity, 'accompanied by splitting deliveries so that they do not exceed the CZK 100,000 ceiling in the context of the reverse-charge regime', raises doubts which cash payments made only after the trader's own customers had paid, missing written contracts and suppliers' virtual seats 'reinforce' (paras 31 f.). SQUADRA is the clearest authority for the burden of proof at the first step: non-payment is not yet 'tax evasion at an earlier stage' as long as fraudulent intent is not shown at least as a well-founded presumption and the alternative explanation is not refuted — directly transferable to the elements of § 25f UStG. MK auto trading shows the other side: in the phone trade, threshold-splitting, cash payments and letterbox seats form a bundle that no single argument can untie. Both groups of warning signs are built into the Supplier Traffic-Light Check for the electronics trade.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 23.07.2026 — 4 Afs 167/2024-54, SQUADRA CZ, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:4.Afs.167.2024.54; Urt. v. 10.07.2026 — 3 Afs 147/2025-36, MK auto trading, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:3.Afs.147.2025.36 — source

EuGH

Opinion in C-470/25: where conditions are created artificially, only the undue advantage is to be withdrawn — not everything

a Polish farmer had artificially created the conditions for aid; the authorities refused the entire payment. Advocate General Ćapeta reads the circumvention clause (Art. 4(3) of Regulation 2988/95, Art. 60 of Regulation 1306/2013) narrowly: only 'the amount that should not have been paid' is to be refused or recovered (points 70 f.); a Member State wishing to withdraw more needs a separate legal basis, otherwise the principle of legality is infringed and refusing the whole amount would amount to punishing the person concerned (points 72, 74 f.) — recovery is an administrative measure, not a penalty (points 60 f.). Quotations translated from the French. On this view the general anti-abuse principle justifies neutralising the advantage, not total withdrawal — precisely the prohibition of over-compensation invoked against multiple denials and cumulative liability in carousel chains (the questions left by Italmoda, § 25f UStG). If the Court follows, the case against multiple assessments gains support of general reach.

Schlussanträge GAin Ćapeta v. 17.09.2026 — C-470/25, E. (Clause de contournement), ECLI:EU:C:2026:771 (Vorlage Naczelny Sąd Administracyjny, Polen) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Moby Dick': Milan court convicts six in the EUR 520 million electronics carousel — confiscation of over EUR 300 million, mafia aggravation

On 11 September 2026 the judge for the preliminary hearing at the Court of Milan convicted six defendants — including one ringleader — of organising and participating in a transnational criminal association, VAT fraud and money laundering; all had opted for the abbreviated procedure with its sentence reduction and received between four years and seven years and two months' imprisonment. The court ordered the confiscation of over EUR 300 million and confirmed the aggravating circumstances of aiding a mafia association and using mafia methods. Between 2020 and 2023 the group had issued invoices for AirPods, laptops and other electronics worth more than EUR 1.3 billion; the damage is EUR 520 million, the overall proceedings involve more than 400 individuals and legal entities, and the judgment is at first instance and open to appeal. The European Chief Prosecutor speaks of mafia organisations 'investing in VAT fraud as a vehicle to launder their criminal proceeds'. The case shows the confiscation dimension of electronics carousels and the plea-bargaining strategy: confessing principals shape the file before intermediate companies are even heard. For dealers who came into contact with such structures this means: secure one's own evidence, demand access to the file, test attribution claims against the standard of individual constructive knowledge — the Evidence Pack and access to the file under Glencore exist for that.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 17.09.2026 — Investigation Moby Dick (EUStA Mailand und Palermo; Urteil Tribunale di Milano v. 11.09.2026) — source

FG

Berlin-Brandenburg Fiscal Court 2 K 2046/25: § 14c UStG only where the specific invoice endangers revenue — the share of risky invoices is to be estimated, Ministry's view 'superseded'

A restaurant with a shisha bar had shown 19 % VAT on all till receipts to guests although the reduced rate applied to food in 2021/2022; the tax office assessed about EUR 81,000 under § 14c(1) UStG. The Second Senate reduces this to about EUR 13,300 (judgment of 25 June 2026, appeal admitted): till receipts above EUR 250 without a named recipient are not an 'invoice' within § 14c (para 30); the provision requires an invoice-specific risk to tax revenue, which is 'excluded from the outset' vis-à-vis final consumers without a right of deduction (paras 37 f., CJEU C-794/23 and C-101/24); where the recipient cannot be identified, the share of risk-bearing invoices must be estimated under § 162 AO, and the contrary view of the tax administration (Ministry letter of 27 February 2024; administrative guidelines 14c.1(1a) sentence 5) 'is, in the Senate's conviction, superseded by the CJEU judgment of 1 August 2025' (para 40). Not an abuse case, but a building block for the legal-consequences side in supply chains: § 14c UStG is 'functionally linked to the right of deduction' (para 37) — where no deduction is at risk, there is no tax debt by virtue of the invoice. This supports the argument against cumulating a § 14c assessment at the issuer with denial at the recipient, and it shows that courts are not bound by administrative instructions — which applies equally to guideline 25f.1. Both belong in every objection against multiple assessments.

FG Berlin-Brandenburg, Urt. v. 25.06.2026 — 2 K 2046/25, ECLI:DE:FGBEBB:2026:0625.2K2046.25.00 (Revision zugelassen; BFH-Az. am 19.10.2026 nicht vergeben) — source

BGH

BGH 3 StR 202/25 (official reports): money merely passed through is no laundering object — EUR 30 million confiscation against a company falls away

Through the accounts of two German limited companies ran 247 transfers from Cypriot companies totalling EUR 32.7 million in a 'shadow finance system' circumventing Russian payment restrictions; the flows were disguised with sham and forged invoices, 158 of which went to the tax office (paras 3 f.). The Munich I Regional Court found 248 counts of money laundering and confiscated EUR 2,387,254 and EUR 30,366,355.99 from the two companies. The Third Criminal Senate quashes the confiscation insofar as it exceeds EUR 9,000 (order of 9 July 2026, released 16 September 2026). Headnote: objects that are exclusively the instrument or the object of an unlawful act 'do not, as a rule, derive from it and therefore cannot in principle be the object of money laundering' (para 13). The former special rule in § 261(1) sentence 3 StGB (old version) — extended in 2001 to tax offences precisely by the Act to Combat VAT Evasion — was dropped in the 2021 reform without any intention to make objects of the offence launderable in general (paras 15–17); no other legal basis for confiscation exists (para 34), and only EUR 9,000 each from subsidy fraud remains (para 35). For supply-chain companies through whose accounts payments linked to sham invoices were 'passed', the order cuts off the laundering lever — and with it confiscation of the entire transfer volume from the third party. For § 370 AO as the predicate offence, only the doctrine of saved expenses remains, on which the Senate does not rule here. If confiscation is ordered against your company, this decision is the first point of review in the attachment and confiscation proceedings handled by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK.

BGH, Beschl. v. 09.07.2026 — 3 StR 202/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:090726B3STR202.25.0 (BGHSt; eingestellt 16.09.2026) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Money Cat' (Cologne): exempt supplies to missing traders in France and Belgium plus input VAT from sham invoices — over EUR 60 million loss

The European Public Prosecutor's Office in Cologne had two suspects arrested and twenty homes and business premises searched in North Rhine-Westphalia and Belgium; the investigation concerns nine suspects of an organisation operating between Germany, France and Belgium, trading in goods 'ranging from protective masks to packaging materials'. A main suspect based in Germany allegedly declared VAT-exempt cross-border supplies to numerous French and Belgian companies suspected of acting as missing traders and at the same time deducted input tax on invoices from companies that provided no genuine goods or services — fictitious invoices worth more than EUR 11 million; the estimated tax damage exceeds EUR 60 million, and money flowed to China and Turkey among other destinations. The classic double pattern — exemption of the supply to the missing trader and input VAT from sham invoices — confirms what § 25f UStG targets in both directions. For suppliers in such sectors, customer checks (VAT ID, proof of transport, plausibility of the customer) are the decisive building block of the audit trail; the Supplier Traffic-Light Check covers customers as well as suppliers.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 16.09.2026 — Investigation Money Cat (EUStA Köln) — source

FG

Lower Saxony Fiscal Court 2 K 28/24 (appeal VII R 16/26): § 71 liability fails without the tax office proving intent — a penalty order does not bind the court

The sole managing director of an entrepreneurial company struck off the register ex officio in 2015 had been held liable under § 69 AO and — to his detriment in the objection decision — under § 71 AO for corporation tax and VAT; a final penalty order existed against him. The fiscal court annulled the liability notice (judgment of 19 December 2024, newsletter 10/2026 of 16 September 2026): the office ended with the deletion before the filing deadlines expired, § 36 AO covers only pre-existing duties, and the tax office had never asked the former director personally to file. For § 71 AO: the tax authority bears 'the objective burden of proof for all elements of the criminal offence', in dubio pro reo applies in fiscal-court proceedings too, conditional intent must be proven 'under the rules of criminal procedure' — and a final penalty order does not bind the court; on the incorrect advance returns the tax investigation office had 'made no findings whatsoever'. The BFH admitted the administration's appeal (VII R 16/26); it concerns the continuing duties of a departed director under § 36 AO. The case is small, the propositions are large: § 71 AO fails where intent is 'evidenced' only by a penalty order and the tax investigators made no findings of their own on the subjective element — the standard situation in liability proceedings against officers and buyers of chain companies. The lawyers and tax advisers of VSK work with precisely this burden of proof in liability proceedings under § 71 AO.

Niedersächsisches FG, Urt. v. 19.12.2024 — 2 K 28/24 (Newsletter 10/2026 v. 16.09.2026; Revision BFH VII R 16/26) — source

EuG

New reference T-435/26: does good faith protect the acquirer in a cross-border margin-scheme chain? — hearing in T-689/25 on the VAT ID on 21 October

Austria's Supreme Administrative Court asks the General Court (OJ C/2026/4690 of 14 September 2026) whether a reseller who bought coins from a German reseller under the margin scheme may claim the non-taxation of the intra-Community acquisition and the domestic margin scheme only if the margin scheme was applied in Germany in conformity with the Directive (Q1), whether § 25a UStG in conjunction with Annex 2 no. 54(c)(cc) UStG is contrary to EU law 'taking into account the actual application of that rule in Germany' (Q2) — and whether it makes a difference 'if the taxable person did not know and could not have known that the German rule … does not comply with EU law' (Q3). Second date: on 21 October 2026 the Fifth Chamber (extended composition) hears T-689/25 (reference from the Austrian Federal Fiscal Court): is communication of the customer's VAT ID under Art. 138(1)(b) of the VAT Directive a substantive condition of the exemption, and does a subsequent invoice correction operate retroactively? Question 3 carries the Kittel standard into the cross-border margin-scheme chain: a bona fide acquirer should not answer for the Directive-infringing practice in the Member State of departure — after T-569/25 the next stage of good-faith protection under the margin scheme. T-689/25 decides how hard the VAT-ID formality under the Quick Fixes (§ 6a(1) sentence 1 no. 4 UStG) bites; until then the qualified check before every supply remains the safest building block of the Evidence Pack.

EuG — T-435/26, Finanzamt Österreich (Vorlage VwGH, ABl. C/2026/4690 v. 14.09.2026); T-689/25, James Howden and Co. (mündliche Verhandlung 21.10.2026) — source

EPPO

EPPO 'Nimmersatt': indictment before the Dresden Regional Court — seven German car dealers charged as accessories to VAT fraud with US salvage cars

The European Public Prosecutor's Office in Berlin has indicted nine suspects before the Dresden Regional Court (indictment filed on 11 September 2026; a first indictment had been declined by the Berlin Regional Court for lack of territorial jurisdiction). According to the indictment, badly damaged salvage vehicles were imported from the United States, cosmetically repaired and resold while customs duties, import VAT and VAT were evaded — damage above EUR 90 million (EUR 15.1 million in duties, EUR 49.6 million in import VAT, the rest in domestic VAT) plus EUR 15 million in attempted evasion; freezing orders of more than EUR 33 million, around EUR 2 million actually secured. 'The other seven defendants are car dealers with shops in Germany', accused of selling the refurbished cars to end customers and thereby participating in a criminal organisation and aiding VAT fraud; the sentencing range runs up to 15 years. The indictment draws the line of participation down to the dealer level: whoever sells goods whose import and tax history 'is not right' is treated as a member of the organisation. For car dealers handling third-country imports, the customs declaration, import-duty assessment, salvage status and previous owners belong in the file; price advantages without a documented reason are the warning sign. That the Berlin Regional Court declined the first indictment also shows that jurisdiction in EPPO indictments can be contested — a point the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK pursue in the tax proceedings alongside the criminal case.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 14.09.2026 — Investigation Nimmersatt (EUStA Berlin; Anklage beim Landgericht Dresden v. 11.09.2026) — source

EuG

General Court 'Trading 4': whoever controls the transport carries the exempt supply

A Latvian fuel trader supplied goods under excise-duty suspension to intermediaries that resold the same day into third Member States; the authority attributed the transport to the second supply because the first supplier knew of the resale, and spoke of a 'VAT fraud scheme'. The General Court answers in purely objective terms: neither duty suspension, nor the e-AD, nor proof that the goods left the country exempts the first supply 'in itself'; what matters is when the power to dispose was transferred for the second time, assessed under the Herst criteria (para 33). Whether mere notice of the resale defeats the exemption is expressly left open (para 46). For chain transactions this means: the allocation of the moved supply is decided on facts, not on presumptions of fraud — and para 33 provides the grid for evidencing transport responsibility: Incoterms, freight costs, carrier selection, rights of instruction. That grid is part of the Evidence Pack for chain and triangular transactions.

EuG, Urt. v. 09.09.2026 — T-614/25, Trading 4, ECLI:EU:T:2026:541 — source

Tschechien

Czech NSS sets a risk-graded due-diligence standard — burden of proof on the authority

An IT trader bought toner and cartridges from a chain with a missing trader; the tax office had warned him months earlier about fraud risks in that product group. The NSS upholds the denial but states the principles that matter to honest traders: denial is the exception, so the authority bears the burden of proving the objective circumstances (para 19); nobody is obliged to buy only from official distributors or at list prices — supplier choice is business autonomy (para 36); register, VAT-ID and invoice checks are elements of commercial prudence whose scope must match the concrete risk level: the more warning signs, the higher the diligence required — without an abstract checklist (paras 40–41). On the result the trader loses, but the court's principles support the concept of a risk-graded verification system: a basic check for every supplier, deeper review on warning signs, a documented reaction to official risk notices. The traffic-light system of the VAT Tax CMS is built exactly that way — a notice from the tax administration is a mandatory entry in its risk register.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 03.09.2026 — 22 Afs 57/2026-66, ExaSoft, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:22.Afs.57.2026.66 — source

EuGH

CJEU C-565/24 'coffee trips': the travel-agent scheme applies even at a negative margin — no input VAT refund, neutrality is a 'principle of interpretation'

An operator of coach excursions with sales events covered only part of the transport costs with the participants' fees and wanted full input VAT. The Court (Second Chamber) — unlike the Advocate General — holds Art. 26 of the Sixth Directive applicable to loss-making excursions (operative part 1, paras 20–23) and denies a refund claim at a negative margin (operative part 2, paras 39–43). The principle of neutrality is a 'principle of interpretation', not primary law capable of overriding a statutory exception (para 27). For fraud cases only para 30 matters: an obligation on the administration to investigate the taxable person's intentions would run counter to the aims of simplification — citing Kittel and Recolta Recycling, para 42. The suspended BFH cases continue as V R 41/26 and V R 42/26. No statement on abuse or constructive knowledge; what remains usable is the ranking 'neutrality as a principle of interpretation' and — in mirror image — the argument against inquiries into intent that the statute does not provide for.

EuGH, Urt. v. 10.09.2026 — C-565/24, P-GmbH & Co. KG („Voyages-café“), ECLI:EU:C:2026:732 (Zweite Kammer; Vorlage BFH) — source

EuG

General Court 'Szytelbiecka': no aggregation of successive supplies without a legal link

A Polish entrepreneur gave her business in equal halves to two daughters who then intended to contribute it to a partnership; the question was whether the gift was a non-taxable transfer of a going concern under Art. 19 of the VAT Directive. The General Court declines to aggregate the two steps because the contribution was not a legal condition of the gift. Fiscal in outcome, usable in method: the Court links successive transactions only where one is a legal condition of the other, never via an 'overall plan' — an argument against the authorities' aggregation of multi-step transaction sequences in supply chains, which the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK deploy in objection proceedings.

EuG, Urt. v. 09.09.2026 — T-366/25, Szytelbiecka, ECLI:EU:T:2026:545 — source

BGH

BGH: no confiscation from the individual where only the company was enriched

The Sixth Criminal Panel quashes confiscation orders against a foundation's board member: where the proceeds accrue to a third-party legal entity, §§ 73(1), 73c StGB are "in principle not" applicable against the acting individual; what is required is a finding "going beyond de facto power of disposal" that he himself obtained something altering his own balance sheet — exceptions only where the entity is a mere "formal shell" without asset separation or every inflow is passed on immediately (para 8). Directly transferable to managing directors and buyers in supply chains from whom the company's 'saved' VAT is to be confiscated as proceeds of crime (§ 73 StGB alongside liability under § 71 AO): without a finding that they personally obtained something, there is no basis for confiscation. With this line the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK challenge confiscation and attachment orders against officers.

BGH, Beschl. v. 23.06.2026 — 6 StR 463/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:230626B6STR463.25.0; Beschl. v. 19.05.2026 — 4 StR 202/26 — source

BFH

BFH autumn docket: retroactive invoices, clawback adjustments, § 42 AO, liability appeals

The BFH's official hearing list adds three supply-chain-relevant cases: V R 6/25 asks whether subsequently issued invoices allow retroactive input-VAT deduction and whether interest must be waived on equitable grounds (Senatex line), V R 18/24 concerns the input-VAT adjustment after a successful insolvency clawback (§ 17 UStG; estate liability), and the First Panel hears two § 42 AO abuse cases on 23 September. V R 6/25 is the opportunity case against invoice formalism as an additional lever of the administration; whoever is in a comparable position should keep their case open until the decision — the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK apply for the objection procedure to be stayed for that purpose.

BFH, Verhandlungstermine und Entscheidungsvorschau (Stand 10.09.2026) — V R 6/25, V R 18/24, VII R 7/23, I R 11/22 — source

Niederlande

Netherlands: trader must prove both material and formal input-VAT conditions

On 19 December 2025 the Hoge Raad, relying on the CJEU, held that the trader must prove both the material (Arts 168, 169) and the formal conditions (Art. 178 VAT Directive) of deduction (r.o. 4.3.3); the authority may demand documents beyond the invoice only where "necessary and proportionate" (r.o. 4.3.4, Arcomet Towercranes C-726/23), and formal defects alone do not justify denial where the material conditions can be verified (r.o. 4.3.5, Barlis 06). The Dutch line confirms the trader's de facto burden of proof for input VAT but expressly limits it through proportionality (Arcomet) and the priority of substance over form (Barlis). In practice this means: alongside the invoice, proof of performance — delivery notes, correspondence, payment records — belongs in the Evidence Pack, to the extent that matches the risk of the transaction.

Hof 's-Hertogenbosch, Urt. v. 15.07.2026 — ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2026:1855; Hoge Raad, Urt. v. 19.12.2025 — ECLI:NL:HR:2025:1958 — source

BFH

BFH: tax authority need not swear to the completeness of a GDPR access reply

A taxpayer requested access and copies under Art. 15 GDPR from his tax office and then demanded a sworn affirmation that the reply was complete. The Ninth Panel refuses: the GDPR provides no legal basis, the civil-law rules (§§ 259, 260 German Civil Code) cannot be applied by analogy within § 32i Fiscal Code, and a damages action under Art. 82 GDPR remains inadmissible without prior out-of-court assertion. Art. 15 GDPR remains the auxiliary tool in carousel cases for obtaining control notices, Eurofisc alerts and audit memos before formal access to the file; completeness cannot be enforced through it. Access to the file itself is therefore based by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK on § 364 AO, Art. 41(2) of the Charter and the Glencore line.

BFH, Urt. v. 30.06.2026 — IX R 2/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.300626.IXR2.25.0 — source

EU-Recht

EU consultation 'VAT and the circular economy': margin scheme and second-hand trade under review — deadline 4 November 2026

On 9 September 2026 the Commission (DG TAXUD) opened a call for evidence and a public consultation on a directive meant to make VAT fit for the circular economy; comments are possible until 4 November 2026, a proposal is announced for 2027. The focus is on the taxation of second-hand goods — i.e. the margin scheme whose abuse the European Public Prosecutor's Office is currently pursuing in the cases of new phones sold 'as used' and used phones sold 'as new' —, circular production chains, the destruction of usable goods and input VAT on company cars. For the trade this is an opportunity to bring in workable rules of proof for second-hand status, chain checks and good-faith protection under Litdana and T-569/25 — and a risk that the § 25a fraud cases serve as the justification for tightening. Trade associations should respond; we support associations and companies in drafting their submissions.

Europäische Kommission, GD TAXUD — Konsultation „VAT and the circular economy“ (eröffnet 09.09.2026, Frist 04.11.2026) — source

EuGH

CJEU C-293/24 (Grand Chamber): breach of the duty to refer while aware of a pending parallel reference contributes to State liability

Two separate Grand Chamber judgments delivered on the same day sharpen Köbler liability for courts of last instance. In C-293/24 (Portugal, transfer of undertakings) the Court finds that a combination of errors of interpretation, disregard of the duty to refer under Art. 267(3) TFEU and the fact that the supreme court 'could not have been unaware' that the same question was the subject of a reference pending before the Court 'contribute to establishing' a sufficiently serious breach of EU law (operative part 1). In C-163/24 (Romania, agricultural aid), by contrast, it denies individual rights under Art. 20 of Regulation 1782/2003 and clarifies that a failure to refer does not, on its own, constitute a breach triggering liability (operative parts 1 and 3). No tax element. Whoever loses a Kittel or § 25f question before the BFH or BGH while the same question is pending in Luxembourg now has, with C-293/24, a concrete yardstick for a State-liability claim — and an argument for expressly and verifiably requesting a reference at the instance level. The lawyers and tax advisers of VSK make that request in every suitable fiscal-court case.

EuGH, Urt. v. 08.09.2026 — C-293/24, Ferreira da Silva e Brito u. a., ECLI:EU:C:2026:723; Urt. v. 08.09.2026 — C-163/24, ECLI:EU:C:2026:722 (jeweils Große Kammer) — source

BGH

BGH upholds guideline-ratio estimates despite BFH criticism, tightens reasoning requirements

The First Criminal Panel dismisses the appeal on sentencing (17 counts of tax evasion) and explicitly engages with the BFH's doubts about the official guideline-ratio collection (X R 19/21) — yet keeps external benchmarking admissible where no closer method exists (paras 5–8). The hoped-for convergence with the BFH line fails to materialise; what is gained are tightened reasoning duties for every guideline-ratio estimate. Whoever challenges the representativeness of the guideline ratios (BFH X R 19/21; Weber-Grellet, FR 2026, 21, 33) forces the trial court to give reasons — the approach with which the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK challenge estimates in tax proceedings.

BGH, Beschl. v. 13.07.2026 — 1 StR 128/26, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:130726B1STR128.26.0 — source

BGH

BGH landmark: binding effect of foreign certificates — broad under EU law, narrow under bilateral treaties

Of three headnotes the third matters for supply chains: EU A1 certificates bind broadly because of uniform CJEU interpretation, the Administrative Commission and infringement proceedings as correction mechanisms (Art. 4(3) TEU sincere cooperation); certificates under bilateral third-country treaties bind only unless "manifestly incorrect on the treaty's wording". Not a VAT case, but structurally analogous: the same reasoning (Art. 4(3) TEU, the CJEU's interpretive monopoly) supports the binding effect of VAT-ID confirmations (§ 18e UStG/VIES) and residence certificates (§ 13b(7) sentence 5 UStG) in the carousel context. The qualified confirmation query is therefore more than a formality — it is evidence that the Evidence Pack secures per supply.

BGH, Beschl. v. 28.04.2026 — 1 StR 269/25 (BGHSt), ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:280426B1STR269.25.0 — source

BFH

BFH: motions to take evidence must be read with their procedural history — no partial "assumed true"

The Tenth Panel sets aside a lower-court judgment for procedural error: motions to take evidence made at the hearing must be read together with prior written pleadings; rejecting them by "assuming the fact true" is permissible only without any qualification. Also in the batch: IX B 34/26 (over-attachment of bank claims remains a case-by-case issue) and V R 35/24 (amended late-filing penalty becomes subject of the pending action under § 68 FGO). The right to have evidence taken in fiscal-court proceedings is, in § 25f and Kittel disputes, the lever against an 'overall assessment' without hearing witnesses — suppliers, carriers, bank staff. The lawyers and tax advisers of VSK make these applications in writing and repeat them at the hearing so that no loss of the objection occurs.

BFH, Beschl. v. 14.08.2026 — X B 28/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:B.140826.XB28.25.0 — source

EuG

General Court: anti-abuse discretion does not defeat direct effect of the VAT Directive

An Austrian sole trader contributed let real estate to his GmbH; Austria confined the transfer-of-going-concern rule (Art. 19 VAT Directive) to certain income categories. The General Court holds the list of permissible restrictions exhaustive and grants direct effect where a Member State has misused its discretion (paras 43–48). Crucially (paras 45–46): a discretion 'to prevent tax evasion, avoidance or abuse' does not render the provision conditional — the State cannot invoke its restriction against a taxpayer able to prove that he falls within the directive's scope. A methodological lever against excessive national anti-abuse implementations: the abuse reservation is no blanket authorisation removing EU-law control of a rule such as § 25f UStG. Whoever proves the conditions of the Directive can rely on it — the proof is the task of the Evidence Pack, the reliance that of the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK.

EuG, Urt. v. 02.09.2026 — T-413/25, Peckeger, ECLI:EU:T:2026:514 — source

Tschechien

Czech Supreme Administrative Court: police interview notes usable as tax evidence without confrontation

A winery was assessed by estimation on the basis of criminal-investigation seizures, phone data and police notes of informal third-party statements taken in the taxpayer's absence. The NSS holds such notes admissible in tax proceedings even though they could not be read in the criminal trial without the consent of prosecutor and accused; the tax authority need not examine the lawfulness of the criminal evidence-gathering itself. A direct comparator to the Glencore line (C-189/18): where criminal-procedure findings migrate into tax proceedings without any right of confrontation, the right to be heard and access to the file (Arts. 41, 47, 48 of the Charter) are hollowed out. In Germany the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK demand in such cases disclosure of the data sources and examination of the informants before the fiscal court.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 20.08.2026 — 22 Afs 22/2026-43, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:22.Afs.22.2026.43 — source

FG

Nuremberg Tax Court: VAT inspection at the adviser's office is no stigma — no declaratory interest

After an input-VAT surplus from a car purchase, the tax office carried out a VAT inspection (§ 27b UStG) at the representative's office and moved on to a special audit. The claimant sought a declaration of unlawfulness because she felt 'branded as a tax evader'; the fiscal court denies any interest in such a declaration — an inspection does not stigmatise. The judgment cuts off two lines of defence that matter in the early phase of carousel cases: the rehabilitation interest against stigmatising inspection measures and proportionality review of the VAT inspection, although § 27b UStG serves in practice as the early pick-up. Preparation for the first contact matters all the more: whoever knows at an inspection what to hand over and what not shapes the further course — that is the subject of the 72h Readiness Check.

FG Nürnberg, Urt. v. 05.05.2026 — 2 K 424/23 (BeckRS 2026, 20714) — source

Tschechien

Czech NSS: "serious doubts" suffice — burden of proof for input VAT shifts to the trader

Input VAT denied across a broad range of services, some CZK 6 million plus penalty. Three key propositions of the NSS: supplier-side invoice defects do not exonerate the recipient — he must close the gap with other evidence; the authority need not disprove the supply — 'serious and reasoned doubts' rendering the records implausible suffice; a business partner's refusal to testify counts against the taxpayer. A textbook example of the de facto reversal of the burden of proof: the doubt standard plus attribution of third parties' conduct undercuts the EU-law requirement that the authority prove the objective circumstances to the requisite legal standard (Mahagében/Dávid, Aquila para 52). Whoever keeps proof of performance beyond the invoice and binds business partners contractually to cooperate removes the ground from this logic — two rules from the Evidence Pack.

NSS (Tschechien), Urt. v. 20.08.2026 — 9 Afs 45/2025-39, NEWCOMMER, ECLI:CZ:NSS:2026:9.Afs.45.2025.39 — source

EuG

EU General Court order UNIX: no input VAT denial without proof — no-loss chain matters

The EU General Court has clarified in a Hungarian case: where goods were actually delivered and every link in the chain declared and paid its VAT, input VAT deduction may not be denied merely because the authority considers the invoicing chain wrongly composed. The tax administration must prove to the requisite legal standard that the trader actively participated in fraud or knew or should have known of it. A double yield: the 'no loss to the treasury' reasoning supports the case against multiple assessments and for an EU-law-conforming reduction of § 25f UStG in neutral chains, and the burden-of-proof formula binds the authority. The lawyers and tax advisers of VSK deploy both where input VAT is denied solely because of a 'wrongly staffed' invoice chain.

EuG, Beschl. v. 30.10.2025 — T-363/25, UNIX (ABl. C/2026/172 v. 12.01.2026) — source

BFH

Sec. 25f before both BFH VAT panels: new appeal V R 31/25 on 'should have known'

The admitted appeal against the Münster fiscal court's precious-metals ruling on the 'should have known' standard of sec. 25f VAT Act has been lodged and is pending before the Federal Fiscal Court as V R 31/25 — with the Fifth Senate, not the Eleventh. The first substantive clarification of the input-VAT denial rule is thus pending in both VAT senates in parallel: V R 28/24 (formerly XI R 3/24) from Thuringia and now V R 31/25 from Münster. The double pendency before the Fifth Senate increases the likelihood of a robust clarification of the standard. Whoever receives an assessment under § 25f UStG today should keep the case open: the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK base objection and suspension application on the serious doubts (§ 69 FGO) that these appeals establish.

BFH — V R 31/25 (Revision gegen FG Münster, Urt. v. 17.03.2025 — 5 K 694/17 U) neben XI R 3/24 — source

BGH

BGH imports the CJEU "wholly artificial arrangement" test into tax crime — no stay under § 396 AO

Where domestic income is routed through an EU-foreign company, the corporate shield falls away in case of a wholly artificial arrangement — the Panel expressly relies on CJEU C-276/22, C-484/19 para 49 and Cadbury Schweppes C-196/04 para 55, listing objective substance criteria (premises, staff, communication means, genuine activity, lived contracts). It also denies any right to a stay under § 396(1) AO at the appeal stage. EU anti-abuse doctrine thus migrates further into the criminal panels, and the restrictive handling of § 396 AO entrenches the practice that criminal courts do not await clarification by the fiscal courts. For businesses with foreign companies this means: substance — offices, staff, contracts actually performed — must be evidenced before anyone asks; the Evidence Pack keeps that proof ready.

BGH, Beschl. v. 29.04.2026 — 1 StR 172/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:290426B1STR172.25.0 — source

Polen

Poland's top court keeps denying input VAT — proof of diligence is decisive

Six decisions of Poland's supreme administrative judges within two days confirm input VAT denials in sham-invoice and supply-chain cases; in one case, tax due on the invoice itself plus a limitation period suspended by criminal tax proceedings come on top. The Polish administration's line continues unbroken; the judgments also show, however, where the traders failed — missing evidence of origin, price and movement of goods. For businesses with Polish counterparties that is the standard against which the Supplier Traffic-Light Check tests the other side.

NSA (Polen), Urt. v. 07.07.2026 — I FSK 1309/23 (CBOSA-Volltext) und Urteile v. 25./26.08.2026 — source

Ungarn

Hungary's Curia restructures VAT denial: four categories, burden of proof on the State

The Hungarian Supreme Court's guidance text sorts input VAT denial into four categories of descending culpability — from fictitious transactions through artificial arrangements and knowing to merely negligent passive participation in another's fraud. In each category the tax authority must prove both the fraud and the respective state of mind; mere non-payment of duly declared VAT is expressly not fraud. The consistently two-tier burden on the authority (fraud plus level of awareness) and the clear separation of case groups form the clearest Member State counter-model so far to the German practice of blending the two. Whoever faces a § 25f assessment in Germany can hold up this model as a test grid: to which case group does the tax office assign the allegation, and has it proven both limbs?

Kúria (Ungarn), Kollegiumsmeinung 1/2025. (XII. 9.) KK vélemény v. 09.12.2025 — source

EPPO

EPPO Munich: five arrests in AirPods VAT carousel — electronics trade in focus

At the request of the EPPO's Munich office, five suspected organisers of a VAT carousel involving wireless earbuds were arrested in Czechia; the estimated damage is €20 million, with accounts frozen in Germany as well. The "Echo" investigation has been running for years and has already produced eight convictions — the chain companies operated across six countries, including Germany. Enforcement density in the electronics carousel sector, with German case management, is rising, and such proceedings run on for years. For dealers with headphones, smartphones and accessories in their range this means: supplier checks and evidence planning must be in place today — the Evidence Pack keeps the proof for deals from years ago within reach.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 26.08.2026 — Investigation „Echo“ (Zentrum München) — source

EuG

EU General Court: no EU action against EPPO appeal — remedy lies with national courts

Convicted in Czechia on an EPPO indictment and given a suspended sentence, the defendant sought to challenge the EPPO's appeal — which seeks five to six years of actual imprisonment — before the EU General Court. The Court dismissed the action for manifest lack of jurisdiction without even serving it on the EPPO: lodging an appeal is a procedural act under Art. 42(1) of the EPPO Regulation, reviewable only by national courts. The gap in judicial protection before the EU courts against incriminating EPPO procedural acts — here even an appeal seeking a harsher sentence — becomes routine under the C-328/24 P line. Judicial protection thus lies with the national courts; there the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK conduct the tax proceedings and coordinate the criminal defence.

EuG, Beschl. v. 22.07.2026 — T-272/26, Lovás/EUStA, ECLI:EU:T:2026:485 — source

FG

Lower Saxony fiscal court: criminal defence costs deductible after VAT conviction

A commercial manager had been given a suspended sentence for VAT evasion committed for his employer's benefit — yet the Lower Saxony fiscal court allowed his criminal defence fees as income-related expenses. The accusation arose from his professional conduct; the statutory deduction ban covers only fines and comparable sanctions, not the defence costs themselves. The cost side of the defence is strengthened: defence fees remain deductible even after a conviction. Whether the costs of a case stick with the company or the managing director at all, however, is decided earlier — in the D&O and criminal-defence cover that our Policy Check reviews for coverage and duties before the emergency.

Niedersächsisches FG, Urt. v. 14.07.2026 — 13 K 108/25 — source

BGH

Federal Court restates estimation rules: stricter standards in tax criminal trials

The First Criminal Panel uses a case of over one million euros in evaded VAT for an almost textbook-style restatement: estimates in criminal tax proceedings are subject to stricter standards than in assessment proceedings — in dubio pro reo, minimum-culpability quantification and a clear hierarchy of methods; tax office or tax investigation estimates may be adopted only after demonstrably independent judicial review. The order joins the Senate's line on the complete calculation of evaded tax (1 StR 557/25, 510/25, 523/25) and adds the complete estimation grid. For tax proceedings this means: every estimate by the tax office or tax investigators is to be tested for method, data basis and the benefit of the doubt — the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK do so in every objection against estimated assessments.

BGH, Beschl. v. 13.07.2026 — 1 StR 267/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:130726B1STR267.25.0 — source

BGH

Federal Court: EPPO argues VAT appeal — waiver of seized cash cuts confiscation

In a Düsseldorf VAT evasion case, the Federal Court of Justice slashed the confiscation orders against two defendants — in one case from some €926,000 to just over €15,000: an effective waiver of seized cash extinguishes the State's value-substitution claim to that extent. The waiver under § 73c sentence 1 StGB is an immediately usable instrument against the double burden of confiscation and a continuing tax claim. When it pays off and how it is to be coordinated with the tax proceedings is assessed by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK together with the criminal defence.

BGH, Beschl. v. 12.05.2026 — 1 StR 319/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:120526B1STR319.25.0 (auf Antrag der Europäischen Staatsanwaltschaft) — source

BGH

Federal Court of Justice: incomplete tax-loss calculation topples conviction

The First Criminal Panel discontinued one count under sec. 154 Code of Criminal Procedure because the trial court had applied the flat 25% rate to hidden profit distributions while ignoring possible loss offsets — expressly continuing its rulings 1 StR 557/25 and 1 StR 510/25. Within months, a firm line has emerged: even deduction items that "cannot be excluded" render the tax-loss calculation legally defective. The line on complete calculation of evaded tax is thus settled Senate case law: every incomplete target-actual computation should be challenged. The tax proceedings alongside the criminal case — liability, attachment, suspension — are handled by the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK with precisely this first point of review.

BGH, Beschl. v. 22.07.2026 — 1 StR 523/25, ECLI:DE:BGH:2026:220726B1STR523.25.0 — source

BFH

Federal Fiscal Court asks CJEU: is a remotely operated plant a fixed establishment?

An Austrian entrepreneur operates a largely automated sludge-drying plant in Germany, monitored from her seat, with on-site work done by a subcontractor. The Fifth Senate asks the CJEU whether such a plant is a "fixed establishment" — which determines whether the supplier herself or the customer owes the VAT under the reverse-charge rules. The Senate's restrictive line protects EU service providers from unexpected domestic VAT liability and supplies arguments in reverse-charge disputes. Whoever operates plant or staff in other Member States should settle the fixed-establishment question before the first invoice — a checkpoint of the VAT Tax CMS.

BFH, EuGH-Vorlage v. 07.05.2026 — V R 12/24, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:VE.070526.VR12.24.0 (jetzt EuG T-555/26) — source

BFH

Federal Fiscal Court: cost recharges without supply trigger VAT, no deduction

A hirer opened its canteen to temporary workers at staff rates and invoiced the staffing company a cost lump sum, which the latter recharged back. The Federal Fiscal Court sees no supply in this mere back-and-forth of charges: no input VAT deduction on the incoming invoices, but VAT owed on the outgoing invoices under sec. 14c(2) VAT Act. Group and contract partners slip into the sham-invoice framework with such recharges; every cost recharge should be checked for a genuine supply before invoicing — a module of the VAT Tax CMS. At the same time the BFH confirms the distinction that helps in supply-chain cases: the § 14c tax is precisely not based on a supply actually made.

BFH, Urt. v. 16.04.2026 — V R 1/25, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.160426.VR1.25.0 — source

BGH

Confiscation cut from EUR 2.66m to 283k: full target-actual comparison required

Germany's Federal Court of Justice requires a complete target-actual computation instead of broad estimates. A strong lever against excessive confiscation in VAT proceedings.

BGH, Beschl. v. 16.04.2026 — 1 StR 557/25 — source

BVerfG

Constitutional Court halts surrender to Poland over unresolved prison conditions

By interim order, the Federal Constitutional Court barred for six months the surrender of a Polish national under a European Arrest Warrant: the Higher Regional Court of Hamm had approved the transfer subject to detention in specified prisons, although the Polish Ministry of Justice had declined to give exactly that assurance. What needs clarification is whether the court met its duties of inquiry under Art. 4 of the EU Charter. The duty-of-inquiry objection under Art. 4 of the Charter acts as a brake on surrender — directly usable where defendants from carousel proceedings are sought under a European Arrest Warrant. Criminal defence counsel raise this objection; the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK keep the tax proceedings open in parallel.

BVerfG, Beschl. v. 11.08.2026 — 2 BvR 1502/26, ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2026:rk20260811.2bvr150226 (einstweilige Anordnung) — source

EU-Recht

New EU directive: genuine compliance becomes a mitigating factor

Directive (EU) 2026/1021 (OJ L, 11 May 2026) establishes EU-wide, for corruption offences, that effective, genuinely implemented compliance programmes of legal persons may count as a mitigating circumstance (Art. 16(c)) — recital 29 expressly discounts mere window dressing. It does not directly cover tax offences; under the new Art. 8(2) of the PIF Directive (Art. 36(4)), however, Member States may extend these mitigating grounds to serious cross-border VAT fraud. Reading the same rationale into a VAT CMS under section 25f German VAT Act is our own assessment — but the EU legislature has now supplied the blueprint.

RL (EU) 2026/1021, ber. eucrim v. 11.08.2026 — source

BVerfG

Constitutional Court quashes surrender to Romania: Art. 4 Charter needs real scrutiny

After the interim order on the surrender to Poland, a decision on the merits follows: the Federal Constitutional Court quashes a Munich court's European Arrest Warrant surrender order to Romania — the review of detention conditions, despite Romanian assurances, fell short of Art. 4 of the EU Charter. Together with 2 BvR 1502/26 (Poland) this forms a robust double line of interim relief and merits against surrenders without clarified detention conditions — an instrument of criminal defence counsel with which the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK coordinate the tax proceedings.

BVerfG, Beschl. v. 05.08.2026 — 2 BvR 364/26 — source

EPPO

EPPO Prague: six indicted over €17.4m import VAT fraud via e-commerce warehouses

The EPPO in Ostrava indicted five individuals and one company: Chinese goods were customs-cleared through import companies only formally registered in Czechia, then notionally supplied VAT-exempt to firms in other Member States — in reality delivered to e-commerce platform logistics centres and sold to consumers across the EU (abuse of customs procedure 42). No new legal proposition, but a warning signal for the e-commerce and import supply chain: customs procedure 42 moves into the enforcement focus next to the classic single-market carousel. Whoever sells through import companies and fulfilment warehouses keeps customs declarations, onward-delivery evidence and marketplace statements in the Evidence Pack.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 03.08.2026 (Ostrava/Prag) — source

BFH

Input VAT on advisory fees even where the business never traded

Germany's Federal Fiscal Court confirms the broad, neutrality-protected right to deduct: advisory costs to enforce damages for a merely intended activity qualify. A rebuff to narrow nexus requirements.

BFH, Urt. v. 07.05.2026 — V R 15/24, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.070526.VR15.24.0 — source

EU-Recht

2025 PIF report: 648 EPPO VAT investigations, €43.84bn in estimated damage

The Commission's 37th annual report on the protection of the EU's financial interests counts 648 active VAT-related EPPO investigations at the end of 2025 — about 18% of all cases but almost 65% of the estimated total damage of €43.84bn. Two findings are valuable for affected businesses: the Commission concedes the damage "mostly impact[s] national budgets", and it describes carousel structures as "infiltrating" genuine, operating companies. The damage figure will fuel enforcement pressure; the report also supplies Commission statements against the presumption of knowledge and against blanket reliance on the Union's financial interests, which businesses can use in objection and court proceedings — the lawyers and tax advisers of VSK do so.

Europäische Kommission, 37. PIF-Jahresbericht 2025, COM(2026) 411 final v. 28.07.2026 — source

EU-Recht

ViDA taking shape: implementing regulation on OSS/IOSS and own-goods transfers

The Commission has published the first technical follow-up act to the ViDA directive: it adapts the electronic filing formats of the One-Stop-Shop schemes and defines the new special scheme for transfers of own goods, replacing the error-prone call-off stock rules from 1 July 2028. Technical but practically relevant: less exposure in consignment and chain transactions, but new formal duties as hooks for objections from 2028. Whoever intends to use the transfer scheme sets up master data and reporting processes now — a project we cover in building the VAT Tax CMS.

Durchführungsverordnung (EU) 2026/1869 der Kommission v. 27.07.2026, ABl. L v. 28.07.2026 — source

EU-Recht

EPPO and OLAF gain direct access to VAT data

Council Regulation (EU) 2026/1743 of 10 July 2026 opens the data of the VAT information exchange system, the CESOP payment data and, from 2030, the central VIES to the European Public Prosecutor's Office and OLAF for targeted queries from 17 August 2027 — with strict purpose limitation, personal user identity and an audit log per query (Art. 49a of Regulation 904/2010 as amended); Eurofisc forwards to the EPPO analysis reports on suspected cross-border fraud schemes. Those safeguards become checkpoints for every defence: each access must be assigned to one investigation and one user and is therefore traceable through access to the file.

VO (EU) 2026/1743, ABl. v. 27.07.2026 — source

EuGH

Liability for another's VAT debt: the company assessment must remain contestable

Under Article 47 CFR, a director held liable must be able to challenge the underlying assessment against the company. Directly usable in German secondary-liability proceedings.

EuGH, Urt. v. 16.07.2026 — C-158/25, ECLI:EU:C:2026:591 — source

BFH

BFH: no liability of accessories after collection limitation (VII R 18/24)

The exception to accessoriness applies to perpetrators only. For mere aiding, sec. 71 liability ends with collection limitation of the tax debt — a hard new checkpoint in favour of taxpayers.

BFH, Urt. v. 21.04.2026 – VII R 18/24, ECLI:DE:BFH:2026:U.210426.VIIR18.24.0 — source

EuGH

ECJ 'Lin II': effectiveness over lex mitior on limitation (C-280/25)

National courts must disapply more lenient limitation standards where systemic impunity for serious EU fraud looms; final decisions remain untouched.

EuGH, Urt. v. 16.07.2026 – C-280/25 (Lin II) — source

EPPO

Berlin court: further convictions in luxury-car/mask carousel

Three further convictions on EPPO charges — including the organisation's tax adviser; over EUR 9m confiscated, also from a benefiting company. Enforcement now reaches advisers and companies.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 14.07.2026 (LG Berlin, Urt. v. 10.07.2026) — source

EPPO

'Huracán': buyers of 'margin cars' targeted — EUR 300m damage

Arrests and searches in DE/PL/NL: enforcement now specifically targets buyers reselling carousel vehicles under the margin scheme. Buying vehicles without documented VAT history is a red flag.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 10.07.2026, Investigation Huracán — source

EuGH

AG Opinion 'Isolanti Group': limits for VAT settlements (C-308/25)

In the AG's view, a settlement requiring only a percentage of the disputed VAT is incompatible with EU law. Judgment pending — relevant for consensual case resolutions.

GA-Schlussanträge v. 11.06.2026 – C-308/25 (Isolanti Group) — source

EuGH

EU court control strengthened: testimony refusal annulled

The EU judiciary annuls a refusal to authorise staff testimony vis-a-vis the EPPO — a small but clear signal for equality of arms and judicial control within the EPPO framework.

EuG, Urt. v. 10.06.2026 – T-99/25 — source

EPPO

'Metallo': further asset recovery in EUR 428m complex

The EPPO secures additional assets in one of the largest ongoing VAT complexes. Asset freezing remains enforcement's fastest sword — and the strongest reason for evidence architecture before the emergency.

EPPO, Pressemitteilung v. 05.06.2026, Investigation Metallo — source

◈ Explore this structure live — infinitely deep